Submersible pump vs trash pump for dewatering
A submersible pump sits in the water and suits deep or confined pits with mostly clean water, while a trash pump sits outside the water and handles muddy water with leaves, sand, and debris.
Key takeaways
- Submersible pumps work underwater and suit deep pits, sumps, and flooded basements.
- Trash pumps sit on the ground and move water with larger solids.
- The amount of debris in the water is usually the deciding factor.
Fall rain fills excavations, trenches, and basements quickly in BC. The right pump clears water fast and keeps work moving.
What is a submersible pump best used for?
A submersible pump is placed directly in the water. Most are electric and run quietly.
They work well for:
- Deep excavations and sumps
- Flooded basements and crawl spaces
- Elevator pits and vaults
- Water with fine silt or small solids
What is a trash pump best used for?
A trash pump sits outside the water and draws it up through a suction hose. Most are gas or diesel powered.
They work well for:
- Muddy or debris-filled water
- Trenches and open excavations
- Water with leaves, sand, and small stones
- Sites without electrical power
Comparing the two side by side
| Factor | Submersible pump | Trash pump |
|---|---|---|
| Placement | In the water | On the ground beside the water |
| Typical power | Electric | Gas or diesel |
| Solids handling | Fine silt and small solids | Larger solids and debris |
| Best for depth | Deep pits and sumps | Shallower suction lifts |
| Noise | Quieter | Louder |
How do you choose the right pump?
Consider three things:
- What is in the water: clean water, silt, or heavy debris
- How deep the water is and how far it needs to travel
- Whether power is available on site
Our team can help you size a pump and the right length of hose for your job.
FAQ
Can a submersible pump handle muddy water? Some can handle fine silt and small solids. For water with leaves, sand, and stones, a trash pump is usually the better fit.
Does a trash pump need electricity? Most do not. Trash pumps are usually gas or diesel powered.
Which pump is better for a flooded basement? A submersible pump is usually preferred because it can sit at the lowest point and runs on electric power.
Need a pump for your next project? Book now with 1st Call Rentals.
Related reading
- Equipment for fall concrete work in BC
- Preparing your job site for BC's fall storm season
- Getting your BC job site ready for winter